Skip to main content
Bandelli Agency, Inc.
Protecting What Matters Most Brooklyn's Trusted Independent Broker Coverage for Every Part of Your Life

Family-owned and independent since 2000. Bandelli Agency, Inc. puts you first.

Your Trusted Independent Insurance Broker

In 1972, Jim Bandelli began serving the New York community with a commitment to integrity, personal service, and trusted insurance guidance. Over the years, his dedication to protecting families, homes, vehicles, and businesses laid the foundation for what would later become Bandelli Agency.

Today, Bandelli Agency, Inc. continues that tradition of excellence. As a family-owned agency representing more than 20 leading insurance carriers, we provide personalized coverage options, competitive pricing, and responsive service tailored to your needs.

When you choose Bandelli Agency, you are choosing experience, reliability, and a team that treats you like family — because protecting what matters most to you is what matters most to us.

Get in Touch
25+
Years Serving
New York
20+
Insurance
Carriers
P&C
Property &
Casualty Specialists
100%
Independent —
We Work For You

Coverage for Every
Part of Your Life

We shop multiple carriers to find the policy that truly fits your needs — not a one-size-fits-all solution.

Homeowners & Condo/Co-op

Comprehensive protection for your home or condo, personal property, and liability — so your biggest investment stays safe.

Renters Insurance

Affordable coverage for your personal belongings and liability — protecting what matters most.

Flood Insurance

Standard policies do not cover floods. We can properly advise you on options for flood insurance.

Auto Insurance

We offer personal and commercial auto coverage from multiple top-rated carriers.

Commercial Insurance

Property, liability, and business coverage tailored to your industry — protecting your livelihood from the unexpected.

Umbrella Policies

An extra layer of liability protection that kicks in when your primary policy limits are reached — peace of mind at its best.

What Our Clients Say

Moving in New York City is incredibly overwhelming with the high demand, fast-paced rental market and everything that comes with it. Finding the Bandelli Agency made renters insurance so easy. They helped me get the right coverage at a great price, and the best part was having one less thing to stress about during my move!

— Renters Insurance Client of 4 Years

I've used Bandelli Agency for both of my businesses over the last 12 years, and have had nothing but positive experiences. They are hard working, dedicated people, who truly care about their clients. They helped me survive the pandemic with timely refunds and low policy quotes, and they always have my back during any issues. I look forward to working with Bandelli for the foreseeable future.

— Commercial Client of 12 Years

I've had the chance to see how the Bandelli Agency treats their customers when insurance and support were most important. There was a fire in my apartment building, and I lost access to my home, all of my belongings and my car. The Bandellis submitted my claims right away and smoothly, arranged initial payments quickly, and helped make sure that my insurance was a support rather than another obstacle in getting my life back together. I take comfort in knowing that if I need help, the Bandelli Agency will be there.

— Auto and Co-op Customer of 15 Years
Our Carrier Partners

20+ Top-Rated Insurance Carriers

Our independence means we shop the market on your behalf — always finding the right carrier for your situation.

Travelers Progressive The Hartford Chubb Kingstone Ocean Harbor Occidental Country-Wide Zurich Amherst Specialty Hyundai Narragansett Bay USLI US Underwriters & More

Professional Affiliations

Independent Insurance Agents
Association of New York, Inc.
Professional Insurance Agents
Get in Touch

Let Us Find the Right Coverage for You

Whether you need a quick quote or want to talk through your options, our team is ready to help.

Call Us
(718) 934-4600
Office Hours
Monday10:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Tuesday10:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Wednesday10:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Thursday10:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Friday10:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Office closed Friday, but agents are available virtually
Saturday & SundayClosed

Request a Quote

We typically respond within one business day.

Thank You!

We have received your request and will be in touch shortly.